Putting a Face on Theatre
For those of you that missed it in the news – A major Broadway Musical production of SpiderMan suffered a serious publicity snafu last week when the aerialist playing Spidey took and unexpected 30 foot dive off of the scenery. (http://theatresafetyblog.blogspot.com/2010/12/spidey-goes-splat.html & http://www.stage-directions.com/theatre-buzz/2925-another-serious-actor-injury-on-spider-man-turn-off-the-dark-agencies-agree-on-more-stringent-safeguards.html & http://www.stage-directions.com/theatre-buzz/2952-actors-equity-president-releases-statement-on-spider-man-injuries.html)
Most of us mere mortals never get to work a show this complex or expensive to produce, however, we do frequently get to place performers and the audience in harms’ way. Let’s look at this kind of risk and see how we might better mitigate it. Here is a recent example that I came across:
The local children’s theatre summer camp decides to present “Once upon a Mattress”, which is a variation upon the fairy tale “The Princes and The Pea”. Set piece needed: A bed with twenty or so mattresses. This gets pretty tall - say about 11 feet tall. You have to be able to move it on / off the stage, the actress playing the princess is about 12 years old, and will have to climb up on top of the bed as a part of the performance.
What could possibly go wrong here?
· Unsecured access – The ladder is not a fixed part of the set piece and has no hooks to lock it to the bed frame or anchor it to the floor. The ladder is leaning against a set piece that is on non-locking casters and is not secured to the floor. The ladder weighs almost as much as the princess. The ladder’s vertical side rails do not significantly extend above the top of the sloped platform, so transition to / from the ladder is difficult at best.. (Note: OSHA standard is for a ladder to extend 36” above the deck.)
· Unplanned movement - The bed frame is on casters that do not lock, so when the performer is climbing or descending the ladder, or moving about on top of the mattresses, the set piece and ladder are both free to move independently of each other.
· The top of the bed is so tall that the tiny actress disappears from the audience’s view, so the top of the bed is raked (sloped) about 10 degrees so she will be more visible. Railings would have “blocked the audiences’ view”, so there were no railings. (Note: OSHA standard is that fall protection shall be utilized whenever workers are more than 72” above the floor.)
So we ask ourselves: What parent sanctions their child to ‘play around’ on the sloped roof of a one story building where they could fall onto a hard floor below? Probably not too many. Did I mention that the parents PAID to have their children in this play?
Who would be responsible if the princess fell?
· The Set Designer / Scenery Builder was a “respected Technical Theatre instructor at a local College”, but did not incorporate any safety features into the set piece like locking casters or floor jacks, did not secure the ladder to the set piece or floor, and did not provide any place to secure the performer to the set piece. The set piece did not appear to have been constructed of fire retardant / fireproof materials.
· The Director / Producer of this play didn’t recognize the potential hazards involved in this scenario and instructed the crew to use this scenery, and directed the 12 year old actress to climb upon it and perform.
· The Costumer did not design-in any way for the actress to wear a fall protection harness under her outfit. It is likely that the costume materials were not treated with fire retardant.
· The Stage Manager and/or Rigger did not see that this could be a potential problem and did not require that any safety precautions be accommodated. No crash-pads on the floor, no interlocks between the ladder and the set, piece, no fall protection equipment, or places to attach a fall restraint lanyard.
· The Theatre Owner was leasing the space to the Show Producer and was reluctant to require any safety precautions be taken for fear that the renter would not return if they required to produce the plays safely.
· The one person that broached the subject of the princess’s safety was ejected from the Theatre.
What could have been done differently? Safety planning must begin with the first production meetings. Hazards must be recognized and addressed early so that solutions can be researched for complexity, cost, and availability. This isn’t limited to just fall protection. This has to address many other items as well.
Theatre is a very collaborative effort, and all the participants must work closely together to mount a show safely. The integration of safety within the culture of the production staff is key to making it a seamless step. Everyone should be free to comment on the methods and materials so that the ‘path of least resistance’ is to do it right, not find excuses.
Ladder Safety Information:
www.elcosh.org/en/document/324/d000305/hazard-alert-ladder-safety.html
Comment
Rich,
The reason you have heard of the mythical code is that much of what we do is unregulated. OSHA has some say in what we do, but when it is students who are not employee's, they are technically out of it. However, you are an employee. So if it affects your safety, then OSHA applies.
Case in point: One of the reasons we, ESTA, have been writing ANSI codes is to have some industry standards that have been written by those of us that supposedly know more than some policy wonk in DC or state capitols.
That said, some suggestions for the above picture:
There is nothing that says all of those mattress' need to be full height. They could be a suggestion of mattress's and make the piece lower in height. Lots of scenery is not, and does not have to be, literal in size and look. With the lower height, the ladder could be made with more steps and the actor could move slower when climbing.
With the lower height, a slight rake would still work. However, I would add a steel tube railing around the perimeter. It could be 1' or more higher and still not cause visual problems with the actress. It could be decorative, something appropriate to a princess’ bed. Then, be sure that the actress is trained thoroughly in how to act safely. One of the ways to deal with some of these artistic vs. safety problems is through good operation. When we make theater as foolproof as a public walkway, we reduce the magic. Let's face it, a theater is a dangerous place. Backstage safety is achieved through safe routine and knowledgeable personnel. (Example: We all are taught to be aware of the stage edge. Rarely, do I see a railing system along the downstage edge. Although, I do often recommend the one way LED edge marker lights that only the performers can see.) With the railing and training/practice, fall arrest may not be needed. Thus making the transitions with a child actress not as complicated. Keep in mind, the people that will be on the bed is a controlled group. Not everybody will be allowed to play on it.
Ted
Comment by Rich Dionne on December 30, 2010 at 8:29pm
Comment by Erich Friend on December 30, 2010 at 8:23pm Candyce,
Good resources for safety information abound. There is so much that it can be a bit overwhelming at times. I'll start-off with a shameless plug for the TheatreSafetyBlog. There you can find many links to products and resources. I have a cache of interesting documents at both DocStoc and Scribd, too (there's a link to those on the TheatreSafetyBlog under 'Reading for the Masses').
Monona Rossol's book Health & Safety Guide for Film, TV, & Theatre should be on everyone's reading list, as should Jay Glerum's Stage Rigging Handbook, and Randy Davidson's Practical Health and Safety Guidlines for School Theatre Operations.
Play Safe!
- Erich
Comment by Erich Friend on December 30, 2010 at 8:11pm Rich,
In general, the rules that govern the construction of stage scenery are the same that govern general construction. This is highly dependent upon the local adopted building codes, but in general, you can look to code manuals like:
Other influences are:
* (or the equivalent for the country in which you are working)
It is possible that your local jusdiction has not adopted the most recet edition of the code(s). However, the most recent edition of the code is usually the best reference as it is developed by a panel of authorities that generally really are making good, well-informed recommendations.
And standards organizations like:
All these books and standards really add-up in cost, so it is sometimes difficult to get the funding to pay for all of them. Make friends with your local code officials, engineers, and architects, and they may let you dig around in their library. The public or university library may also have many of these documents, and a school campus safety department will usually have these, too. Unfortunately, not having the books is not an excuse for not knowing the regulartions that affect you.
The most serious items on stage usually involve Fall Protection and Structural Strength.
So, what's this mean? Juliet's balcony needs to be strong enough that she won't come crashing through it and fall to the floor, and simple things like high platforms either need to have railings (which the director may not like) or the performers need to have fall protection harness within their constumes and be tied-off to secure points. This isn't the big visual disruption that some people would like to make of it - when you enter the inner lobby for KA at the Las Vegas MGM, there are performers standing on a narrow ledge above the audience and they are tied-off to the wall behind them. I think I may have been the only one to notice this (but that's because I'm looking for this type of thing).
On the other end of the spectrum - theatre folks are always looking for exceptions to the rules - there are ADDED special requirements for theatres. The NFPA and other building codes have many special construction requirements for theatres and public assembly spaces that do not apply to conventional costruction of commercial and residential buildings.
Another good resource for understanding structural requirements is Alan Hendrickson's book Mechanical Design For the Stage.
-Erich
Comment by Candyce Iseminger on December 30, 2010 at 7:10pm
Comment by Rich Dionne on December 30, 2010 at 11:43am Look at how that ladder gets narrower as it gets taller! I imagine the princess had some trouble finding her footing as she got closer to the top!
Speaking of "Spider Man": the actress playing Arachne (injured a few weeks ago during previews) is leaving the production: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/29/theater/29spider.html.
Nice post, Erich. A common question amongst the TD grads at Purdue is, fortunately, does it need railings or not? Although OSHA has specific codes related to safety railings and harnesses, can you speak to how those codes relate to on-stage scenery and theatrical performers?
Theatreface is the networking site for professional, educational and community theatre brought to you by Stage Directions Magazine.
84 members
64 members
357 members
Start Your FREE Subscription to Stage Directions Today!
SD covers everything from backstage to box office--performance to production and is filled with practical tips and information you need to stay on top of theatre trends.Start getting your own copy today!
© 2015 Created by Stage Directions.
You need to be a member of TheatreFace to add comments!
Join TheatreFace