Putting a Face on Theatre
The last two weeks we’ve looked at the physics involved in moving, stopping, and holding in place a fairly large scenic platform. Last week, I mentioned in the comments that a good friend of mine, Rod, who works as a civilian engineer for the army, had some things to say about last week’s post (you can see his comment here). He raises important considerations that I thought were worth examining, and we’ll take a look at them, below.
Before I do, though, Rod’s comments raise a more important, general issue: a technical director, in many situations, has to be an engineer without being an engineer. To do this effectively and safely requires a delicate balancing act, and a willingness to admit that you don’t know all of the answers.
Certainly, to have to admit, “I don’t know,” makes me very nervous—as it should any technical director. However, I firmly believe that being able to recognize when I don’t know something actually makes me a more competent and stronger technical director: I need to know what I don’t know, and either get that information, find someone who does know it, or otherwise account for it to keep people safe.
For the most part, I see two types of students in my classes: the first are those who rely on past practices and experiences, and eschew any quantitative analysis of structures, mechanisms, or even scheduling. As one might expect, often these students either overbuild a unit, spending more money than they need to, or underbuild it, requiring them to go back and add supports or gear trains or whatever. The second type of student I see tends to be the exact opposite: once they’re introduced to calculations and formulae to generate a reasonably accurate quantitative analysis of a phenomenon, they get a little heady with their own—relatively limited—knowledge, and believe they know everything they need to know, and have considered every angle.
Of course, the perspectives of both of those types of students do our true engineering colleagues a major disservice, by either devaluing the importance of what they do day in and day out, or by devaluing the amount of study and knowledge is required to do what they do. However much we as technical direction students (make no mistake, I’m still learning and still consider myself a student) learn about applied engineering practices, we’ll never be engineers.
Much of what we do in theatre—as Erich Friend will attest, I’ve no doubt—is inherently dangerous. As I say to my students in many of my classes: what we do sometimes has the very real potential to kill or maim someone. Being able to make analyses of the static forces in a structure or the forces required to overcome friction absolutely sheds light on some of the dangers involved in a particular unit or situation. However, we have to recognize that those calculations give us only a small picture of all of the things going on in that unit, and all of the potential dangers.
If we only know a little bit about what’s going on, what do we do? I tell my students—and this is my personal practice—be conservative. If you anticipate, based on what you’ve been told by the director and seen in rehearsal, that five actors will be on a platform, plan for more. If you anticipate they’ll be doing some dancing, plan for a knock-down, drag-out fight. By planning for the worst-case scenario, you provide some headroom in your design for the unexpected to happen, as well as to account for things you can’t quantify.
Of course, there’s a finite limit to how effective this can be: at a certain point, no amount of over-estimation will account for everything. This is the point when you seek more knowledgeable and experienced colleagues. Unfortunately, there’s no hard-and-fast rule for when to look for more help; for myself (and what I encourage my students to consider), if I have any doubt at all—even a slight tickle in the gut—I ask for another set of eyes. It can’t hurt, and it can only help.
Back to the moon platform, and Rod’s comments. Essentially, Rod raises three things to consider:
Of course, in all three cases he’s absolutely correct.
From the beginning of this project we’ve planned to mount the pneumatic cylinders such that when they are fully extended, they will just barely lift the platform off the deck—only as much as about 1/8”, at the most. I should have made that much clearer in last week’s post. Unfortunately, by not making that clearer—for you or for me—I neglected to remember this fact when demonstrating the total pressure considerations. As Rod points out, if the cylinder can extend far enough so that the feet are just barely lower than the casters, no amount of pressure in the system will lift the platform any further. Consequently, we can achieve a higher pressure in the system, and a higher amount of applied force between the rubber feet and the deck.
Given that, if we roughly double the amount of pressure—to, say, 100 psi—we’ll now see a force delivered by each foot of 4.9in2 x 100psi, or 490 pounds. With four feet, we’ll be delivering a total downward force of 1,960 pounds. When we run this through our equations for determining the force required to overcome static friction (Ff=uFN), we get a total lateral force required of about 1600 pounds.
In other words, once we put to rest Rod’s first to considerations, we can see that we shouldn’t have any concerns that actors bouncing around on top of this thing will cause it to shift from side to side.
That is, of course, provided the air pressure remains constant, which is Rod’s third point. This is one of those cases where I don’t have the training to analyze the kinds of dynamic forces and fluid compression considerations Rod raises as valid concerns. Consequently, I can’t quantify the effect those forces will have on the pneumatic system and its ability to hold the platform in place.
However, I can anticipate what the worst might be and plan for that. For starters, keeping the air pressure below the maximum capacity of our fittings protects the system and the components from explosive failure due to pressure spikes introduced by any jumping motion on top of the wagon. Additionally, by mounting the cylinders so that they extend only a fraction of an inch beyond the casters means the total volume change we can expect if compression occurs is small: 1/8” x the total area of all four cylinders (19.6 in2), or about 2.5 in3. The total volume of air in our system when the rubber feet are down is approximately 764 in3; consequently, because the volume change is relatively small if all four feet are compressed by the action on top of the platform (764 in3 to 760 in3), the pressure spike in the system will be small, according to Boyle’s law:
P1V1=P2V2
where P1 is the initial pressure, in psi
V1 is the initial volume, in in3
P2 is the final pressure, in psi
V2 is the final volume, in in3
If we substitute 764 in3 for V1, 760 in3 for V2, and 100 psi for P1, we can find P2: 100.5 psi. This is still well below our capacity of 150 psi; additionally, because we’re venting to air as we extend and retract the cylinders during the performance, our total air pressure will drop over the course of each performance—we’ll find ourselves with even more headroom in air pressure.
This doesn’t address Rod’s question about oscillations in air pressure, and the possibility that, at least momentarily, the air pressure in the system will drop below that required to hold the platform in place. I think that we’ve left room for that possibility as well: if you look carefully at the analysis, we calculated for the worst-case lateral motion, which is nearly impossible for someone to impart. In order for the actors to generate pressure oscillations, they’ll need to be jumping more up and down and less side-to-side—and imparting significantly less lateral force in the bargain, which means they wagon will be less inclined to want to move side to side. We also know, based on discussions with the director, that while there will be dancing on top of the unit, it won’ t be mosh-pit-style movement; we have a very safe expectation that the quick, jerking, full-body-weight motion we’ve described is a worst-case scenario is very unlikely to actually occur. That’s the reason we calculated for that scenario: this gives us some “headroom” in our estimates that allows for things we can’t really predict or calculate.
All of which is a long way of pointing out that we’ve tried, in our overall design of the wagon (some of which I’ve glossed over in previous posts, mostly for time and clarity) to take into account all of the things we can know, and to allow room to accommodate for the things we don’t know. Rod’s question about oscillating air pressure certainly bore examination—and I encourage anyone out there who does know the mathematics involved in an analysis of that type to show us how it’s done!—but I’m confident that the steps we’ve taken to over-estimate the forces we can analyze leaves us with a robust-enough design to accommodate this phenomenon.
(It’s probably not relevant, but I want to give Rod a shout-out: we’ve known each other for a long time, and don’t always—well, rarely, actually—see eye-to-eye on a whole variety of topics. That’s one of the reasons I value his perspective so much: our debates always challenge me to think deeper and more fully about any topic—including this one. I’m fortunate to have friends who do that for me.)
Next week: Pics of the system, and pics of actors on the moon for the first time in rehearsal.
Tags:
Theatreface is the networking site for professional, educational and community theatre brought to you by Stage Directions Magazine.
© 2011 Created by Jacob Coakley.
You need to be a member of TheatreFace to add comments!
Join TheatreFace